So many stories, such as that to follow, are probably a lot funnier in real life and/or in my head than they are when rendered in typewritten black and white on the page. But here goes.
We’ve been working on bedtime with K. . . well bedtime and daytime and whineytime and mealtime, generally all-time. He’s been a bit of a challenge lately. A cute, smart challenge, but nonetheless. So I put him to bed and tell him: This is it. After I leave, it’s bedtime and I’m not going to talk to you anymore or come in here. If you say, “Mommmmm I need XXXXX,” I am going to say “Goodnight K.” And that will be that.
Right. In my head, that will be that.
So this night he agrees to my terms, I leave to do dishes, and return upstairs an hour later, congratulating myself on a job well-done. He finally gets it, I say. My consistence and clear communication are working, I pat myself on the back. Clear sailing ahead.
At the top of the stairs I hear, “I need a different pillow.”
I visibly deflate.
Then say firmly, “Good night K.” (That is, after all, our deal.) He cries, he screams, he tosses things around his room. At one point, he walks out holding pillows A and B in his outstretched arms, “These pillows are not good.” He throws them, I collect them and they go away (another deal: You throw it, you lose it).
Then he goes to get pillow C and carries that out, still wailing. “This pillow is not comfortable.” Pillow C is thrown, picked up, gone away.
All this time, he is following me out of his bedroom. I turn around and walk him back in; he runs ahead of me and jumps into bed. I turn to leave, he follows me out. You get the idea. . . this goes on and on. He is wailing; I don’t speak. With every fiber of my being, I hate doing this. But I know from experience that if I stop and talk to him, or reason with him, or tuck him in, then we start over. So I continue.
All the windows are open; it’s 10pm. I can only assume that everyone in the neighborhood can hear what’s going on. It’s a little embarrassing.
Then on one of his trips back into his bed, he slips and falls, bumping his heel on the bedframe. Wailing increases tenfold. Now it’s not only, “Mommy, mommy, mommy, please listen to me mommy. PLEASE.” It escalates to “Mommy, mommy, mommy, owie, mommy owie, it hurts. Owie, mommy, PLEASE.”
So what do you think the neighbors are thinking NOW? T even comes in, looking concerned, to see what is going on. Needless to say, I have not touched K, have barely looked at him. Now it’s a lot embarrassing. I close the windows to spare the neighbors (and probably implicate myself further if anyone really *is* listening).
And here, finally, is the hardest part for me to think about. After about 30 minutes he gathers his composure, as best a very upset 3.75 year old can. Through his sobs, which become swallowed and muffled in his attempt to calm himself, he says, “Excuse me mommy, could I please have a different pillow.”
It hurts me to type this, but I didn’t give him one. I walked him back to bed. First and foremost in my mind was: BE CONSISTENT. And whoo-boy was I consistent, but I don’t think I did the right thing. I honestly don’t know what I should have done and this nutshell represents my hardest parenting moment. I don’t know if I did the right thing.
He has an anger problem; he throws toys and kicks and hits and screams. I am really struggling with how best to teach him and help him and guide him. I remember that anger; I’m pretty sure I was the same way. How can I help him?
I know that I will have moment after moment like this throughout the years. Indeed F is showing signs of her own magnificent temper. I need to figure this out.
To end the story, however, after 60 hellish minutes, K fell asleep. By that time his disdained/beloved pillows were gone, his bedsheet was gone, his diaper was gone (pulled off by him), his stuffed animals had all been thrown and confiscated. My small, dear, sweet, sweet boy was sprawled asleep, naked on his naked bed. I love him.